Opinions, oh no!
These are the games of the year from 1999-2010 (so far). These are just my opinions so feel free to disagree, but then again that is your opinion. So here goes, 11 years of the top 3 games.
1999
Game of the year
Mario Party - N64
Runner Up
RollerCoaster Tycoon - PC
Honorable Mention
Donkey Kong 64 - N64
Mario Party - N64
Runner Up
RollerCoaster Tycoon - PC
Honorable Mention
Donkey Kong 64 - N64
2000
Game of the year
Diablo 2 - PC
Runner Up
The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask - N64
Honorable Mention
Counter Strike - PC
Diablo 2 - PC
Runner Up
The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask - N64
Honorable Mention
Counter Strike - PC
2001
Game of the year
Silent Hill 2 - PS2
Runner Up
Grand Theft Auto III - PS2
Honorable Mention
Super Smash Bros. Melee - Game Cube
Silent Hill 2 - PS2
Runner Up
Grand Theft Auto III - PS2
Honorable Mention
Super Smash Bros. Melee - Game Cube
2002
Game of the year
Metroid Prime - Game Cube
Runner Up
GTA: Vice City - PS2
Honorable Mention
The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind
Metroid Prime - Game Cube
Runner Up
GTA: Vice City - PS2
Honorable Mention
The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind
2003 (Honorable Mention)
Game of the year
Knights of the Old Republic - Xbox
Runner Up
Jak 2 - PS2
Honorable Mention
Warcraft III: The Frozen Throne - PC
Knights of the Old Republic - Xbox
Runner Up
Jak 2 - PS2
Honorable Mention
Warcraft III: The Frozen Throne - PC
2004 (Top year)
Game of the year
Half Life 2 - PC
Runner Up
Call of Duty: United Offensive - PC
Honorable Mention
Jak 3 - PS2
Half Life 2 - PC
Runner Up
Call of Duty: United Offensive - PC
Honorable Mention
Jak 3 - PS2
2005 (Runner Up)
Game of the year
Resident Evil 4 - Game Cube
Runner Up
God of War - PS2
Honorable Mention
Destroy All Humans - PS2
Resident Evil 4 - Game Cube
Runner Up
God of War - PS2
Honorable Mention
Destroy All Humans - PS2
2006
Game of the year
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion - PC
Runner Up
Saints Row - Xbox 360
Honorable Mention
Gears Of War - Xbox 360
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion - PC
Runner Up
Saints Row - Xbox 360
Honorable Mention
Gears Of War - Xbox 360
2007
Game of the year
Bioshock - Xbox 360
Runner Up
God of War 2 - PS2
Honorable Mention
Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare - PS3
Bioshock - Xbox 360
Runner Up
God of War 2 - PS2
Honorable Mention
Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare - PS3
2008
Game of the year
Fallout 3 - PS3
Runner Up
Gears Of War 2 - Xbox 360
Honorable Mention
GTA: IV - PS3
Fallout 3 - PS3
Runner Up
Gears Of War 2 - Xbox 360
Honorable Mention
GTA: IV - PS3
2009
Game of the year
inFAMOUS - PS3
Runner Up
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 - PC
Honorable Mention
Bat Man: Archem Asylum - PS3
inFAMOUS - PS3
Runner Up
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 - PC
Honorable Mention
Bat Man: Archem Asylum - PS3
2010 (So Far)
Game of the year
God of War 3 - PS3
Runner Up
Splinter Cell: Conviction - Xbox 360
Honorable Mention
Heavy Rain - PS3
Mass Effect 2 - Xbox 360
God of War 3 - PS3
Runner Up
Splinter Cell: Conviction - Xbox 360
Honorable Mention
Heavy Rain - PS3
Mass Effect 2 - Xbox 360